Outside of the restaurant, Chica was idly looking around for pizza when she noticed a Pizza Bros truck passing by. The younger brother immediately screamed in fear as he exploded. Deciding to play a prank on Luigi, Mario wore a Bonnie Head to scare Luigi, who was passing by the office. While looking around and passing a sign that read that the spaghetteria was redesigned for Fazbear's Fright (setting the reference to Five Nights at Freddy's 3), Mario found a box filled with animatronic heads in the security office. Mario and Luigi, the latter who was holding a chainsaw in fear, enter the spaghetteria.

When they got there, Mario demanded Luigi to hurry up while Chica, who secretly stalked them, just stared at the two entered the restaurant. Shocked, Luigi tried to get off but Mario revealed he already bolted the door from the outside, much to Luigi's horror. While driving to the restaurant, Luigi wondered why Mario took him, who responded that he was a sacrifice for the animatronics. ( Chica the Chicken thought it was pizza but Mario threw the monitor at her because she was wrong). Trying to drag Mario away from the computer (while he was complaining that he had to do this because all the spaghetti shops were closed), the computer showed some spaghetti news about Freddy Fazbear's Pizza being closed but still having some spaghetti, much to Mario's joy. When SMG4 demanded to know Mario's reasoning, he claimed that he had to keep it a secret from Luigi who then revealed that he already knew about Mario's activities. He tip-toed to the light to turn it on to discover that it was Mario in the nude looking at pictures of spaghetti. As it snuck into SMG4's room and used his computer, SMG4 was awoken by the figure typing away on his computer. The video starts with everyone in Peach's Castle asleep except for one shadowy figure.

Mario is back and it appears there is still spaghetti inside an old spaghettria! oh boy! letsa gooo!

Mario in animatronic horror night 6